Optimize your Amazon RDS costs by identifying and transitioning non-critical Multi-AZ deployments to Single-AZ configurations. CloudFix’s RDS Retype Single Availability Zone Finder/Fixer helps you target RDS instances that don’t require high availability, potentially saving up to 50% on these database costs.

Contents

What Does This Finder/Fixer Do?

This Finder/Fixer identifies Amazon RDS instances and clusters configured with Multi-AZ deployments that can be optimized by converting to Single-AZ deployments. It focuses on non-critical environments where high availability might not be necessary, allowing you to significantly reduce costs without impacting appropriate workloads.

By analyzing usage patterns and costs, the Finder identifies candidates for conversion and estimates the potential savings. While this Finder provides recommendations, the actual conversion requires manual implementation since it impacts database availability characteristics.

Why Is This Important?

Multi-AZ deployments are an excellent feature for mission-critical production workloads, providing automatic failover and high availability. However, they come at a significant cost premium—typically double the cost of a Single-AZ deployment—because you’re essentially running two synchronized database instances.

Many organizations inadvertently provision Multi-AZ deployments for non-critical workloads for several reasons:

  • Configuration is copied from production to development/test environments
  • Default templates or IaC modules enable Multi-AZ by default
  • Over-provisioning during initial deployment without subsequent optimization
  • Legacy databases that have been repurposed but never reconfigured

This represents a significant cost-saving opportunity without affecting appropriate workloads, as many development, testing, and non-critical deployments don’t require the high availability that Multi-AZ provides.

How Does The Finder Work?

CloudFix uses several criteria to identify RDS instances that might be candidates for converting from Multi-AZ to Single-AZ:

  1. Deployment Configuration Analysis: Identifies all RDS instances and clusters using Multi-AZ deployments.
  2. Cost Impact Assessment: Focuses on instances with significant annual costs (typically over $100 annually, based on the last 31 days of usage).
  3. Savings Calculation: Determines if the potential savings exceed 15% of storage costs.
  4. Workload Pattern Analysis: Examines usage patterns to identify non-production workloads.

The Finder presents candidates that meet these criteria along with the estimated annual cost savings from converting to Single-AZ. The decision to implement the change remains with you, allowing you to evaluate each case based on your specific requirements and risk tolerance.

What Happens When The Fixer Runs?

This recommendation requires manual implementation as it involves making a significant configuration change to your database infrastructure. CloudFix provides detailed information to help you make an informed decision, but does not automatically modify your RDS deployments.

To convert from Multi-AZ to Single-AZ, you would typically:

  1. Evaluate: Confirm the database isn’t serving critical workloads requiring high availability.
  2. Plan: Schedule the change during a maintenance window to minimize impact.
  3. Implement: Use the AWS Management Console, CLI, or API to modify the instance.
  4. Verify: Ensure the database functions properly after the conversion.

Using the CLI, the conversion can be performed with a simple command:

aws rds modify-db-instance \
    --db-instance-identifier your-db-instance-identifier \
    --no-multi-az \
    --apply-immediately

If you prefer to apply the change during your next maintenance window, omit the --apply-immediately flag.

AWS Services Affected

Amazon RDS
Amazon RDS

Benefits

  • Significant Cost Reduction: Up to 50% savings on eligible RDS instances (PostgreSQL, MySQL, MariaDB, etc.) and up to 24% for SQL Server Enterprise Edition.
  • Resource Optimization: Aligns database deployment configuration with actual workload requirements.
  • Improved Cost-to-Value Ratio: Ensures you’re only paying for high availability where it’s needed.
  • Simplified Management: Reduces complexity for non-critical environments.
  • Enhanced Cost Visibility: Identifies under-optimized database deployments across your organization.

Potential Risks

Converting from Multi-AZ to Single-AZ involves several important considerations:

  • Reduced Availability: Single-AZ deployments don’t provide automatic failover capabilities, increasing risk of downtime during AWS maintenance or infrastructure failures.
  • Maintenance Impact: Database maintenance operations may cause longer downtime in Single-AZ deployments.
  • Disaster Recovery: Without a standby replica, recovery from instance failures will take longer and rely on point-in-time backups.
  • Application Expectations: Applications designed with high-availability assumptions may need reconfiguration.

Before implementing this change, evaluate your workload criticality, backup strategy, and acceptable recovery time objectives (RTO) to ensure alignment with business requirements.

Cost Savings

The cost savings from converting Multi-AZ to Single-AZ deployments are substantial:

  • For PostgreSQL, MySQL, Oracle, and MariaDB: Up to 50% savings on instance, storage, and IOPS costs.
  • For SQL Server Enterprise Edition: Up to 24% annual cost reduction.

These savings come primarily from eliminating the standby replica instance and its associated storage. For example, a db.m5.large Multi-AZ PostgreSQL instance in US East costs $0.342/hour, while the equivalent Single-AZ deployment costs $0.171/hour—a direct 50% saving.

With database costs often representing a significant portion of cloud spending, targeting non-critical Multi-AZ deployments can yield substantial overall savings, especially in larger environments with many database instances.

FAQ

How do I identify which RDS instances are appropriate to convert?

Focus on non-production workloads like development, testing, QA, and staging environments. Consider workloads where the availability requirements don’t justify the additional cost of Multi-AZ deployments. Always consult with application owners to verify availability requirements.

Will switching to Single-AZ cause downtime?

Converting from Multi-AZ to Single-AZ typically involves minimal disruption if the --apply-immediately parameter is used. Without this parameter, the change occurs during the next maintenance window. Brief connectivity loss may occur during the transition.

How does this affect my backup strategy?

In Multi-AZ deployments, backups are taken from the standby instance to avoid performance impact on the primary. After converting to Single-AZ, backups will occur on the primary instance. Review and potentially adjust your backup windows to minimize impact on critical workloads.

Can I convert back to Multi-AZ later if needed?

Yes, you can convert back to Multi-AZ at any time using a similar process. The transition to Multi-AZ involves creating and synchronizing a standby instance, which can take time depending on the database size.